268 – What Really Happened To Jimmy Hoffa? Psychics, UFOs, and The Irishman

Mike Huberty • October 17, 2019

July 30th, 1975. Former Teamsters Union President James R. Hoffa is scheduled for a 2PM meeting at the Machus Red Fox Restaurant in Bloomfield Township, Michigan with reported Mafia members, Anthony Provenzano and Anthony Giacalone. At 2:15pm he calls his wife and expresses his annoyance that no one is there. At 3:27pm, he calls his friend Louis Linteau and says he was stood up. After that, no one hears from him again.

What Really Happened To Jimmy Hoffa? Psychics, UFOs, and The Irishman
Jimmy Hoffa

In a mystery that has never officially been solved by law enforcement and has been the basis of massive speculation as well as the source of a million late night comedy jokes over the years. Jimmy Hoffa, one of the most well-known figures of all time in organized labor politics, just vanished without a trace.

He wasn’t an angel. Hoffa had already been convicted of fraud and illegal wiretapping and had served several years in prison, and he several of his associates had admitted that they were in the mafia. In order to unify local trucking unions and rise to power, he had to cut deals with organized crime figures who were central to the running of the unions. He was the focus of Robert F. Kennedy’s corruption investigations in the early 1960s. Jimmy Hoffa was surrounded by criminals and eventually he angered the wrong people. But who did he anger and how did he disappear? That’s the mystery.

And the story is back in the news because it’s one of the central tales in Martin Scorcese’s new film, The Irishman , coming out this month. It’s based on the life of Frank Sheeran, a union leader, Hoffa associate, and a hit man for the Bufalino crime family. Sheeran claims to have killed Hoffa in his book, I Heard You Paint Houses (which was the code phrase people used to approach him to perform an assassination.) While that’s one theory of what happened to him, we delve into far-out ones in this episode. Some topics we cover:

This week’s track, inspired by the idea of vanishing without a trace is called “The Disappeared”.

When I say your name
There’s no answer on the way
I forget you were erased
because you were here one day
and it’s almost like I imagined

It’s a mystery
how you disappeared from my history
Oh It’s like you never existed
Oh It’s like you never existed.

Exit reality
to only remain in my memory
oh It’s like you never existed
Oh It’s like you never existed.

Just a fantasy
a phantom limb that itches me
Just a missing piece of meat
a sailor lost at sea
vanished and abandoned

It’s a mystery
how you disappeared from my history
Oh It’s like you never existed
Oh It’s like you never existed.

Exit reality
to only remain in my memory
oh It’s like you never existe

gangsters in front of a car
By Mike Huberty January 19, 2026
Our St. Valentine's Day Massacre Ghost Tour Pub Crawl in Chicago is back Friday February 13th, 2026 at 8pm with a romantic twist!
Group of ghost hunters in Lake Geneva
By Mike Huberty January 9, 2026
30 minute ghost tour for 2026 Winterfest in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin
Hotel 1829 in Charlotte Amalie
By Mike Huberty December 31, 2025
Discover haunted St. Thomas in the Virgin Islands with Hotel 1829’s history in Charlotte Amalie... then join our St. Thomas ghost walk to explore it.
December 23, 2025
A Spirited Start: A Guide to Haunted New Year's Eve Traditions
 La Rogativa San Juan
December 20, 2025
Discover the legend of La Rogativa in Old San Juan, a historic candlelit procession, haunted plaza, and ghostly tradition still felt after dark.
Night Marchers in Hawaiʻi
December 15, 2025
Discover the legend of Hawaiʻi’s Night Marchers, ancient warrior spirits said to roam by moonlight. Explore the myth and join a ghost tour this holiday season.
Olimpia Maidalchini by Diego Velázquez
By Ben Messenger December 11, 2025
Walk in the haunted footsteps of Olimpia Maidalchini in Rome, Italy
Ghost Host with the Most Lisa Van Buskirk celebrating Milwaukee Krampusnacht with a Krampus cosplay
By Mike Huberty December 3, 2025
Milwaukee's craziest Christmas party, Krampusnacht, and American Ghost Walks is proud to be part of it.
America's Haunted Holiday Destinations
November 19, 2025
Explore America’s haunted holiday destinations, where Christmas cheer meets ghost stories, historic hotels, haunted theaters, and chilling seasonal folklore.
Halloween in Virgin Islands
October 16, 2025
Celebrate Halloween 2025 in the Virgin Islands with parades, parties, and haunted tales. Explore island legends on Ghost Tours with American Ghost Walks.