201 – Lost Over Lake Michigan: The Disappearance of NWA Flight 2501

Mike Huberty • June 20, 2018

On June 23rd, 1950 there were 55 passengers and 3 crew on North West Orient Airlines Flight 2501 flying from New York City to Seattle. It was scheduled to stop over in Minneapolis but air traffic control lost communication with the plane shortly after it left Michigan and the plane was never heard from again.

Lost Over Lake Michigan

An oil slick was found a few miles from the coast and some “shredded wreckage” and human body parts eventually wound up washing to shore (enough to form a mass grave, even if the identities were never revealed), but nothing else of the plane was ever found. It was the worst aviation disaster in American history up to that point. There was a horrible thunderstorm that night over the lake and it was also a busy night for air traffic.

Could it have been lighting that hit the plane? Could they have flown too low to avoid traffic and crashed into the water? What happened? Valerie van Heest of the Michigan Shipwreck Research Association thinks she has some answers to why the plane went down, but without finding the rest of the plane, can never be sure.

Author Clive Cussler (the guy who wrote Sahara,  which in my opinion is a fun underrated popcorn movie!) has formed the National Underwater and Marine Agency and has helped fund a yearly search for the past 15 years.

A shirtless man is doing exercises on a dock near the ocean.
Matthew McConaughey getting ready to dive in himself and look for NWA Flight 2501

However, there’s more to this than meets the eye. Major Donald Keyhoe, one of the original flying saucer authors had claimed to have a government source that it might have been a UFO that the flight crashed into. Indeed, there were dozens of reports across the United States of UFOs that night. Allison from Milwaukee Ghosts  has done lots of research on the paranormal possibilities here. As we reach the 68th anniversary and the search begins again, was the fuselage removed because there was something that we weren’t supposed to find? In this episode, we dig in deep.

And since we’re discussing one of Lake Michigan’s greatest disappearances, we thought we’d use a Sunspot song this week about one of our own great disappearances. In 2002, we played some shows with a band in San Antonio and Austin, Texas called Racketbox. They were all military guys  from Fort Hood in Killeen and played loud fun in-your-face punk rock. Anyway, their guitarist was mysteriously only known as Mr. Foff. That’s it. The only thing we could find on Racketbox was an incomplete Purevolume profile and even then it only listed a guitar player as Michael Jackson (and they said it was THE Michael Jackson, who was still alive in 2002).

From sharing Jack Daniels with him in his band van to seeing him rock out onstage, we never had a chance to learn his real name but we spent a lot of meaningful time with this Texas Wildman, even partying with him and his band members until the wee hours of the morning as 2002 passed into 2003 at some afterbar in Austin where it was impossible to find a cab and these were the days before GPS and Uber anyway. We went back to Wisconsin and in March the Iraq War started (on a night we were playing in Springfield, Illinois was when the Shock and Awe campaign began). Next time we went back to Texas was in May and we couldn’t find anything more on Racketbox or Mr. Foff. Four years later, we wrote a song about him on our album  Neanderthal. 

Good night, Mr. Foff. Wherever you are.

Another night, 12 other $h!tt* bands,
Nothing to do, just sitting on our hands.

Then somebody new came into town,
He got us drunk, yeah, he turned the beat around.

And I’d like to know what happened to you Mr. Foff,
Did you leave the band? Do you still drink in the van?
And I’m happy to say I met you that day, Mr Foff,
Will we ever meet again?

Illustrated man, the ink on his skin tells the tale.
Teen runaway, he’s done some time in jail.

Even though the show was pretty lame,
He earned our respect, but we never knew his real name.

And I’d like to know what happened to you Mr. Foff,
Did you leave the band? Do you still drink in the van?
And I’m happy to say I met you that day, Mr Foff,
Will we ever meet again?

And I’d like to know what happened to you Mr. Foff,
Did you leave the band? Do you still drink in the van?
And I’m happy to say I met you that day, Mr Foff,
Will we ever meet again?

(What happened to you, Mr. Foff?)
I’d like to know what happened to you, Mr. Foff.
I’m so glad we met that day, Mr. Foff.
With that long black hair and that bada$$ leather jacket,
You’re my man,
You’re my man,
You’re my man with Jack in the van,
Mr. Foff.

The Conjuring 2
By Allison Jornlin June 9, 2025
Discover the chilling true events of the Enfield Poltergeist—the real-life haunting that inspired the hit horror film The Conjuring 2.
The Conjuring House at Night
By Allison Jornlin June 6, 2025
Is the Conjuring movie fake or is it all terrifyingly real? The latest news about the Conjuring House includes the true story. Get all the info on Andrea Perron and Ed and Lorraine Warren and a new, upcoming Conjuring movie. Plus Zak Bagans investigates, but not before the Ghost Hunters who investigated way back in 2005. We show you where you can watch this historic episode starring Jason Hawes, Grant Wilson, and special guest star John Zaffis, the nephew of Ed and Lorraine Warren. Unfortunately today Jason Hawes and current owner Jacqueline Nuñez are embroiled in a nasty controversy, which forced the closure of the Conjuring House to paranormal tourism in 2024. Get ready to separate fact from fiction! At American Ghost Walks, we're only interested in the real ghosts and real spooky fun.
Japan Airlines Flight 1628
By Allison Jornlin May 25, 2025
In 1986, a Japan Airlines crew saw a UFO over Alaska—an encounter that still baffles experts. Explore one of aviation’s most chilling mysteries today.
A herd of Woolly Mammoths roam
By Allison Jornlin May 23, 2025
Native legends and credible eyewitness accounts suggest that woolly mammoths might still roam remote Alaskan tundra.
Haunted Places in Anchorage,
May 22, 2025
Uncover Anchorage’s creepiest spots with ghost stories, haunted hotels, and eerie encounters that will thrill any paranormal explorer.
The Haunting of Mary Hart
By Allison Jornlin May 22, 2025
Mary E. Hart, a prominent Alaskan journalist, vowed never to return to Nome. A ghostly coffin photo and Mary's haunting, personal account explain why.
A woman in a white dress is standing in a dark hallway
May 20, 2025
Uncover the haunted history of the Historic Anchorage Hotel—chilling tales, ghost sightings, and eerie encounters await in this legendary Alaskan landmark.
Bluebeards Castle
April 13, 2025
Discover the haunted history of Bluebeard’s Castle in St. Thomas and find out how you can visit this legendary site.
Jumbies of the Virgin Islands
April 13, 2025
Explore the haunted history of St. Thomas and meet the legendary Jumbies of the Virgin Islands. Discover real tales, local rituals, and eerie sites on this unforgettable ghost tour adventure.
Ursuline Convent New Orleans
March 4, 2025
Discover the haunting history of the Old Ursuline Convent in New Orleans—legends of vampires, ghostly nuns, and eerie secrets await. Dare to explore? #NewOrleans #HauntedHistory #AmericanGhostWalks
More Posts