186 – The Slenderman Mysteries: Investigating the Internet Bogeyman with Nick Redfern

Mike Huberty • March 6, 2018

In May of 2014, a vicious crime shocked Wisconsin and made headlines across the United States. Two junior high school girls attempted to stab their friend in a sacrifice to an Internet horror story known as “The Slenderman”. While the victim thankfully survived, it left the world wondering, why would these girls commit such a horrible crime and what is The Slenderman?

The Slenderman Mysteries
The pic that started it all

Created as part of a challenge on an Internet forum to create a scary paranormal character, artist Eric Knudsen Photoshopped a tall faceless figure with tentacles on his back around some kids and featured some creepy text. It was a scary pic and the popularity of the character exploded over time as people added the Slenderman  to more and more images and created short text stories that people could copy and paste on Internet forums. The common slang for “copy and paste” is “copypasta” and people adapted that term for horror stories and called it “creepypasta”, which was extremely popular with young teens (who love horror stories, I know I did!)

Unfortunately, young people can become obsessed with stories, especially dark ones, and that can lead some to horrific behavior like we saw in Waukesha. But beyond that, people are starting to have actual “Slenderman sightings” in the real world. Are people’s obsessions creating tulpas, and giving form to a fictional Internet Bogeyman?

As a prolific author of books and articles, Nick Redfern is always on the forefront of the paranormal community. We’ve had him on the podcast before  and we’ve been dying to bring him back. This time he’s released a new book,  The Slenderman Mysteries,  and Allison and I get all the details.

Full disclosure, Allison and I are both featured in the book.  As lifelong Wisconsinites, whenever something unusual happens here that has a relationship with the paranormal, we try to check it out thoroughly. I had my own experience near Waukesha , Allison discovered a strange coincidence,  and indeed Wendy Lynn is tour guide for Waukesha Ghost Walks , so we all have a stake in what happens and how it’s represented.

slenderman mysteries by nick redfern

It’s a lively and informative conversation and some of the things that Nick uncovered in this book are fascinating and terrifying. He is extremely respectful of the tragedy while exploring all the avenues and we reflect that in this discussion.

Also, since Nick is a massive Ramones fan, we had to do a Ramones tribute for this episode. It’s Sunspot inspired by the Ramones with a song about “The Slenderman”.

9 foot tall in a suit and tie
Oh Oh Oh the Slender-man
He came from the woods to terrify
Oh oh oh the Slenderman
He’ll crawl inside your headspace
It looks like he erased his face.

From the basement of the Internet
and made out of belief
are we peeking through the Gates of Hell
when we close our eyes to dream?
They thought that he was fiction
But he’s creeping into fact
and when you feel long arms around you
you best dare not turn your back.

Your nose bleeds and you’re sensing dread
Oh Oh Oh the Slender-man
the Pied Piper of the World Wide Web
Oh oh oh the Slenderman
Ooh those tentacles are gross,
Comin’ through Lovecraftian cosmos.

From the basement of the Internet
and made out of belief
are we peeking through the Gates of Hell
when we close our eyes to dream?
They thought that he was fiction
But he’s creeping into fact
and when you feel long arms around you
you best dare not turn your back.

 

Halloween in Virgin Islands
October 16, 2025
Celebrate Halloween 2025 in the Virgin Islands with parades, parties, and haunted tales. Explore island legends on Ghost Tours with American Ghost Walks.
Halloween in Puerto Rico
October 16, 2025
Celebrate Halloween in Puerto Rico with haunted attractions, ghost tours in Old San Juan by American Ghost Walks, and spooky island adventures.
Halloween in Red Wing
October 16, 2025
Celebrate Halloween in Red Wing, MN with haunted tours, trunk-or-treats, and spooky events. Explore the town’s mysterious past with American Ghost Walks.
By Paul Reyes October 15, 2025
Halloween in Lahaina is unlike any other celebration in Hawaii. Once described as the “Mardi Gras of the Pacific,” Lahaina’s Halloween has been a tradition since the late 1980s, drawing thousands of locals and visitors alike. Whether you are looking for family-friendly fun, lively nightlife, or a glimpse into Maui’s spooky history, Lahaina offers it all.  In 2025, the spirit of Halloween is stronger than ever as the community rebuilds and reopens after the devastating wildfires of 2023. This year’s festivities carry a special meaning by celebrating resilience, culture, and the joy of gathering together on Maui’s most famous street.
October 15, 2025
Celebrate Halloween 2025 in Wiscasset, Maine with parades, trunk-or-treats, and haunted history. Discover spooky stories with American Ghost Walks.
October 15, 2025
Join these Halloween 2025 events in Kennebunkport, from trick-or-treating on Summer Street to spooky Ghost Tours by American Ghost Walks along Maine’s coast.
Thalia Hall in Chicago
By Mike Huberty October 14, 2025
Discover Thalia Hall’s spirits: historic theater lore, staff sightings, and a hands-on ghost hunt Oct 26 at 6 PM. Limited spots.
Halloween in Hilo
October 14, 2025
Celebrate Halloween in Hilo with family events, parties, and haunted fun. Discover Hawaiian legends on Ghost Tours in Hilo with American Ghost Walks.
By Paul Reyes October 14, 2025
Discover why New Orleans is one of the best places to celebrate Halloween in 2025. Explore haunted mansions, voodoo legends, and ghost through walking tours.
By Paul Reyes October 14, 2025
Discover the best Halloween events in Chicago 2025 including parades, haunted houses, pumpkin patches, and nightlife. Join American Ghost Walks for in Chicago!