158 – Fool Us: Magic and Mystery with David Parr

Mike Huberty • August 22, 2017

Magician David Parr’s recent appearance on Penn & Teller: Fool Us ended up with David performing a neat card trick with Alyson Hanigan (Willow from Buffy !) that not only amazed the crowd, but managed to fool both of the title stars! The show is based around the famous magic duo trying to figure out tricks by other magicians and if they can’t figure your trick out, you get to perform with them at their Las Vegas show! On the August 7th episode, David Parr was the only one who managed that feat!

In addition to just being an incredible performer, though, David brings a cast knowledge of magical and mystical history to his show. He has a special Spiritualist-type magic performance in addition to his stage show ( which you can see in Chicago at The Magic Cabaret ) where he delves into the history of the seance as well as the spectacle.


David Parr
David Parr looking like he wants to trick you!

In this episode, Allison from Milwaukee Ghosts joins Wendy and I as we talk to David Parr about his favorite tricks, the whole experience of being on the Penn & Teller: Fool Us program, the problem with modern skepticism, non-staged and unexpected paranormal experiences during magic shows, and of course, miniature guillotines that kids used to get as presents (WHAT?!)


David Parr and the Miniature Guillotine
David Parr and his Miniature Guillotine

Well, one of the things that we discussed in the podcast with David Parr was that humans really love mysteries! That feeling of wonder and “not knowing” helps keep life interesting and fun, and magic is definitely part of that. We all love being fooled a little bit, whether it’s willfully getting engaged in the suspension of disbelief during a movie or watching a lady being sawed in half onstage, or even in our relationships. There’s what’s real and what we want to believe, and often, it’s just more fun to say to the person we love, “Lie to Me”.

Tell me I’m the biggest,
tell me I’m the best.
Tell me how hard I feel
and I’m better than the rest.

Let me know how good my kisses taste,
You’ve never felt this way before
Tell me how every other boy,
left you wanting more.

I can smell the bull$&^% on your breath.

Lie. To. Me.
Lie. To. Me.
Tell me I’m your big daddy,
Everything you’ve ever dreamed.
Lie. To. Me.
Lie. To. Me.
I’m the only one you need,
The only man who can compete.

I love it when you fool me baby
I love it when you fib
I love it when you make me feel
I’m just the best that there is

I’d rather live a fantasy
then suffer through the truth
And your sweet little fictions
Are all I need for proof

I can smell the bull$&^% on your breath.

Lie. To. Me.
Lie. To. Me.
Tell me I’m your big daddy,
Everything you’ve ever dreamed.
Lie. To. Me.
Lie. To. Me.
I’m the only one you need,
The only man who can compete.

The Golden Tiki Bar in Las Vegas
By Mike Huberty January 25, 2026
Step into Las Vegas’ Golden Tiki, a tropical bar with poltergeist tales, eerie bathroom voices, a sinister mermaid, and even Aleister Crowley’s ashes.
gangsters in front of a car
By Mike Huberty January 19, 2026
Our St. Valentine's Day Massacre Ghost Tour Pub Crawl in Chicago is back Friday February 13th, 2026 at 8pm with a romantic twist!
Group of ghost hunters in Lake Geneva
By Mike Huberty January 9, 2026
30 minute ghost tour for 2026 Winterfest in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin
Hotel 1829 in Charlotte Amalie
By Mike Huberty December 31, 2025
Discover haunted St. Thomas in the Virgin Islands with Hotel 1829’s history in Charlotte Amalie... then join our St. Thomas ghost walk to explore it.
December 23, 2025
A Spirited Start: A Guide to Haunted New Year's Eve Traditions
 La Rogativa San Juan
December 20, 2025
Discover the legend of La Rogativa in Old San Juan, a historic candlelit procession, haunted plaza, and ghostly tradition still felt after dark.
Night Marchers in Hawaiʻi
December 15, 2025
Discover the legend of Hawaiʻi’s Night Marchers, ancient warrior spirits said to roam by moonlight. Explore the myth and join a ghost tour this holiday season.
Olimpia Maidalchini by Diego Velázquez
By Ben Messenger December 11, 2025
Walk in the haunted footsteps of Olimpia Maidalchini in Rome, Italy
Ghost Host with the Most Lisa Van Buskirk celebrating Milwaukee Krampusnacht with a Krampus cosplay
By Mike Huberty December 3, 2025
Milwaukee's craziest Christmas party, Krampusnacht, and American Ghost Walks is proud to be part of it.
America's Haunted Holiday Destinations
November 19, 2025
Explore America’s haunted holiday destinations, where Christmas cheer meets ghost stories, historic hotels, haunted theaters, and chilling seasonal folklore.