The Haunting of Shaker's Cigar Bar

September 3, 2024
The Haunting of Shaker's Cigar Bar
5

It's a spooky tale of dismal disaster, as we dive into the spooktacular history of Shaker's Cigar Bar in Milwaukee, WI.  This famed location offers many things including, cigars, fine spirits (literally) and a tale of a dark history that has followed this historical location since the 1800's.

Here are some of the experiences the locals who frequent Shaker's Cigar Bar have reported:

  • Disembodied voices are heard throughout the women's bathroom. The bathroom stall door opens randomly and for no reason at all by forces unseen.
  • Moving objects have been reported in the Penthouse and guests have sighted a woman's apparition.
  • Guests report and eery and uneasy feeling in the basement. The doors in the basement shake like an earthquake and without warning. It's also been reported that women have felt something "pull" their hair in the basement and an old safe moves about the floor.

History

The Haunting of Shaker's Cigar Bar

Although the history of this bar dates back to the late 1890s, many events have been said to have happened within the building. It's been a site for Schlitz Brewery and a soda bottling site.  


It's said that the land on which it was built was surrounded by an Indigenous cemetery before it was built.  


In the 1920s and 30s, it's reported that Shaker's Cigar Bar became a speakeasy and it was said to be operated by Frank & Al Capone.  


It's rumored to have been a brothel in the top 2 floors of the building.  Prostitutes who were all said to be teenagers,  mobsters, and gamblers frequented the brothel which was in operation until 1945. It was frequented by the warehouse district workers who worked and resided in the area. A young girl named Elizabeth was said to have died on the property after falling out of an apple tree on this land and breaking her neck.  


Many people have died in this building including a teenage prostitute who was brutally murdered by a jealous client, a bartender who was skimming earnings from a gambling match, gamblers who were found cheating, and many, many more.  


In 1986, Bob Weiss purchased the building and the heads of all the manifestations that had been proclaimed to have been a part of this bar's history. He tried to keep it in its spooky glory, with dark woods, very little light, amazing food for foodies, and delicious drinks and spirits—yes, literally.  



The Haunting of Shaker's Cigar Bar

Over the years, numerous visitors and staff have reported unexplained events and ghostly encounters. 


Some claim to have seen full-body apparitions, while others have experienced strange sounds, cold spots, and even objects moving on their own. 


Visitors and staff alike have recounted eerie experiences that are hard to explain. On the third floor, which once served as a brothel, many have reported seeing the spirit of a young girl named "Molly," believed to have died under tragic circumstances. 


Some guests claim they've seen her standing in the hallway or felt her presence near the staircase. Others have heard unexplained footsteps and whispers in the otherwise empty rooms.


In the basement, which was once used as a storage area for the bar's illicit goods during Prohibition, there have been reports of shadowy figures and objects moving on their own. 


Some employees refuse to go down there alone due to the overwhelming feeling of being watched or followed. Cold spots, which are commonly associated with paranormal activity, have also been frequently reported throughout the building.


One of the most unsettling experiences involves the apparition of a woman in a white dress, often seen in the upstairs bar area. Patrons and staff have described seeing her out of the corner of their eye, only for her to vanish when they turn to look directly at her. This figure is often associated with the building's brothel days, adding another layer of mystery to the haunting.


Shaker's Cigar Bar fully embraces its haunted history, offering ghost tours that delve into the building's past and the numerous paranormal reports. These tours provide a chance to explore areas of the bar not typically open to the public and hear firsthand accounts of ghostly encounters. 


Whether you believe in the supernatural or are just curious, the stories and experiences at Shaker's make it a must-visit spot for anyone interested in the paranormal.


Cigars, Spirits, Great Food,Paranormal Activity & Ghost Tours



Discover the Haunting Secrets of Milwaukee – Book Your Ghost Tour Today!


Ready to experience the chilling tales and eerie mysteries that haunt Milwaukee? Join American Ghost Walks for an unforgettable journey through the city’s most haunted locations. Whether you're a history buff, a paranormal enthusiast, or simply looking for a spine-tingling adventure, our guided ghost tours offer something for everyone. Don't miss your chance to explore the dark side of Milwaukee!


Book a Ghost Tour in Milwaukee, WI and step into the shadows—if you dare! Check our Milwaukee, WI ghost tour reviews on Google to see what others are saying. Ready for a haunting adventure?

Milwaukee Paracon 2025 logo
By Mike Huberty September 3, 2025
Experience Milwaukee Paracon 2025 on October 18 at the Irish Cultural and Heritage Center—an all-day, free paranormal conference featuring ghost stories, urban legends, UFO sightings, Wisconsin folklore, expert speakers, and unique vendors. Register now for Brew City’s top supernatural event
Jeffrey Dahmer in court
By Mike Huberty September 2, 2025
Explore the chilling legacy of Jeffrey Dahmer from true crime horrors to paranormal legends. Haunted hotels, cursed graffiti, and the Oxford Apartments haunting keep the Milwaukee Cannibal’s story alive in Wisconsin folklore.
ghost of Marilyn Monroe
By Mike Huberty August 28, 2025
Explore the mysterious death of Marilyn Monroe, her ghost sightings in Los Angeles, and the surprising UFO conspiracy theories linked to her story.
Ghost hunters in Dillinger Alley behind Chicago’s Biograph Theater
By Mike Huberty August 27, 2025
Discover the chilling story of John Dillinger’s death at Chicago’s Biograph Theater and the ghostly legends that followed. Explore Dillinger’s Alley and see it for yourself on the Original Chicago Hauntings Ghost Bus Tour.
ghost tours for bachelorette parties
By Mike Huberty August 23, 2025
Looking for a unique bachelorette party idea? Ghost tours are fun, spooky, and unforgettable, perfect for brides and their best friends.
magic in the night sky
By Mike Huberty August 19, 2025
Discover why real magic is more than fantasy. Drawing on Dean Radin’s Real Magic and decades of parapsychology research, this blog explores telepathy, psychokinesis, rituals, and the role of consciousness in shaping reality.
Roberto Clemente sliding into a base
By Mike Huberty August 18, 2025
Celebrate Roberto Clemente’s birthday by exploring his baseball greatness, Puerto Rican pride, humanitarian legacy, eerie assassination threat, and haunting premonitions of his own death.
Tempest Oyster Bar in Madison, WI
By Mike Huberty August 15, 2025
Explore the chilling past of Tempest Oyster Bar in Madison, WI—once a funeral home, now a top seafood restaurant and one of America’s most haunted bars. Funeral home history, Heaven’s Gate legends, and personal encounters await.
The Sunset Strip Killers: The True Story of Doug Clark and Carol Bundy’s Murder Spree
By Mike Huberty August 11, 2025
Discover the chilling true story of the Sunset Strip Killers, Doug Clark and Carol Bundy, whose 1980 murder spree terrorized Los Angeles.
Jim Lovell Astronaut F UFO
By Mike Huberty August 9, 2025
Remembering Captain Jim Lovell, the Milwaukee-born astronaut who led Apollo 13 to safety, piloted Apollo 8, and witnessed the famous Gemini 7 UFO sighting. Explore his Wisconsin roots and space legacy.