Ghosts of Milwaukee's First Unitarian Society

Allison Jornlin • April 29, 2020

Milwaukee's First Unitarian Society

The First Unitarian Society of Milwaukee is well-known for its commitment to social justice with a history distinguished by abolitionism and charity. The congregation originated in Milwaukee in 1842 and moved into the current church building in 1892.

A large brick building with arches and a large window

Today the congregation, ministers, and staff continue their tradition of activism through many efforts including the promotion of environmentally sustainable lifestyles and the open inclusion of the LGBT community. However, in 1894, according to a Milwaukee Journal article from December 22nd, this church was best known for a ghostly apparition which frequently appeared at its front entrance.

A newspaper article about a unitarian ghost that goes to church nightly

Luminous Specter

On dark nights this luminous specter, the glowing outline of person, was often seen. The phenomenon became the talk of the community and soon inspired a copycat prankster. According to the following Milwaukee Journal from December 25th, 1894, a young lady masquerading as the ghost narrowly escaped being shot as she fled from a police officer. As she ran her white sheet flew off and she was subsequently apprehended.

A newspaper article about a ghost 's shroud lost

Unfortunately, the actual phantom was much more elusive. Whatever it was — optical illusion, Marian apparition, or the Ghost of Christmas Past — we may never know. To my current knowledge, this flickering phantasm has long since passed into antiquity.

Uncover the Ghostly Secrets of Milwaukee’s First Unitarian Society

Step into Milwaukee’s mysterious past with a ghost tour that takes you to the historic First Unitarian Society. Known for its commitment to social justice, this landmark also has a spine-chilling secret—a ghostly apparition that haunted its doors in the late 1800s. Imagine encountering the luminous specter that once captivated Milwaukee, with stories of eerie sightings and mysterious figures lighting up dark nights. Whether you’re a history lover, a fan of the paranormal, or just looking for an adventure, our Milwaukee ghost tour will leave you with chills and unforgettable tales. Check our Milwaukee, WI ghost tour reviews on Google to see what others are saying about Us!

Book your Milwaukee Ghost Tour today and discover the hidden haunts of the First Unitarian Society… if you dare!

Find Your Next Paranormal Experience

Milwaukee Bloody Third Ward Ghost Walk

Learn More

Shadow of City Hall Downtown Milwaukee Ghost Walk

Learn More

< Older Post

Newer Post >

The Conjuring House: Is the Haunting Real or Fake?

By Allison Jornlin • June 6, 2025

Is the Conjuring movie fake or is it all terrifyingly real? The latest news about the Conjuring House includes the true story. Get all the info on Andrea Perron and Ed and Lorraine Warren and a new, upcoming Conjuring movie. Plus Zak Bagans investigates, but not before the Ghost Hunters who investigated way back in 2005. We show you where you can watch this historic episode starring Jason Hawes, Grant Wilson, and special guest star John Zaffis, the nephew of Ed and Lorraine Warren. Unfortunately today Jason Hawes and current owner Jacqueline Nuñez are embroiled in a nasty controversy, which forced the closure of the Conjuring House to paranormal tourism in 2024. Get ready to separate fact from fiction! At American Ghost Walks, we're only interested in the real ghosts and real spooky fun.